Share This Article:
Employers Must Prove Nonexistence of Jobs; Workers Don’t Have to Show Job Openings: Pa. Top Court
22 Nov, 2026 Frank Ferreri
Case File
According to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, the state's mandate requiring an employer to offer an available job to a claimant before establishing earning power via a labor market survey also requires the employer to affirmatively demonstrate compliance with this prerequisite by proving, by a preponderance of the evidence, that there is no available job for the claimant. While a claimant may introduce evidence of an available job opening to rebut the employer’s offer of proof, the claimant is not required to, as the claimant does not have the burden.
Case
Thomas v. Sysco Foods, No. 65 EAP 2024 (Pa. 11/17/26)
What Happened?
A forklift operator for a food services company suffered an injury while acting in the course and scope of his employment that necessitated the amputation of his lower left leg.
Eventually, the parties agreed to classify the injury as a lower left leg amputation with a resulting adjustment disorder consisting of anxiety and depressed mood elements, resulting in a weekly compensation rate of $978, based on an average weekly wage of $1,483.85.
Later, the company sought a modification, claiming there was work generally available in the labor market that would provide the operator with an earning power of $660 per week and reduce the weekly benefits to $549.18 a week.
In support of the proposed modification, the company attached a labor market survey that observed that a functional capacity evaluation revealed that the operator's physical capabilities did not match the company's job demands. The labor market survey did not identify any specific available position with the employer, leading to a dispute over which party bore the burden of proving whether such a position existed.
A Workers' Compensation Judge denied the company's Petition for Modification, reasoning that the company didn't offer credible evidence to prove there were no light-duty jobs available at the time of the injury.
On appeal, the Workers' Compensation Appeal Board reversed, concluding that the company was not obligated to present evidence demonstrating the nonexistence of an available job. Instead, the burden was on the operator to show that a job was available.
The operator appealed to court, and the Commonwealth Court affirmed, agreeing that the opeartor was required to present evidence of an available position at the company before the company was obligated to provide evidence in opposition thereto.
The operator appealed to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.
Rule of Law
Under the Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Act, an employer who wishes to modify, reinstate, suspend, or terminate the benefits actively being paid to a partially disabled claimant must establish the claimant's earning power.
Section 306(b)(2) of the act requires an employer to offer a claimant any available job vacancy the claimant is capable of performing before relying on an earning power assessment based on jobs in the general labor market.
The act defines "earning power" as "the work the employee is capable of performing" and authorizes an employer to establish earning power by hiring a vocational expert to conduct a labor market survey -- or earning power assessment -- detailing jobs in the general labor market that the expert believes the claimant could perform.
If the employer has a specific job vacancy the employee is capable of performing, the employer must offer that job to the employee.
What the Pennsylvania Supreme Court Said
In the court's analysis, the placement of the burden of proof was part of the employer's overall burden and not as a defense to a claimant.
"No reasonable person can dispute the conclusion that an employer bears 'superior knowledge and access to evidence' regarding its own employment capabilities," the court wrote. "Whether a multinational employer with entire departments dedicated towards staffing concerns, or a simple mom-and-pop shop, only the employer itself has the 'peculiar means of knowledge' of its current employment capacity."
The court also noted that a worker would be at a "unique disadvantage" in collecting information from the employer to use in proving a defense, as "he would only have the knowledge available to him through external sources, such as job postings or depositions."
Conversely, it "is a relatively easy burden for the employer to satisfy" because, in the court's view, an employer "would be perfectly justified in relying on any one of its human resources employees' testimonies that there are no jobs available, and a WCJ may find that testimony sufficient."
Verdict: The Pennsylvania Supreme Court reversed the order of the Commonwealth Court and remanded for the reinstatement of the WCJ's order.
Takeaway
In Pennsylvania, placing an affirmative burden on an employer to demonstrate that it is not attempting to rid itself of its injured workers through a labor market survey would aid in "attaining the object" of the mandate of workers' compensation law by guaranteeing that the employer cannot offer a job because none exists. Additionally, this burden is also in line with the longstanding "commonsense perspective" that once a worker has established an entitlement to benefits, the employer should bear all burdens in reducing such benefits.
Workers' Comp 101: Offering an Available Job to a Claimant in Pennsylvania
In Pennsylvania, an employer's duty to offer an available job to a claimant may be satisfied if the employer demonstrates:
(1) The employee was notified of a job vacancy and failed to respond.
(2) A specific job vacancy was offered to the employee that the employee refused.
(3) The employer offered a modified job to an employee that the employee refused.
(4) No job vacancy existed within the usual employment area.
AI best practices california case file caselaw case management case management focus claims compensability compliance compliance corner courts do you know the rule employers exclusive remedy florida fraud glossary check Healthcare hr homeroom insurance insurers iowa kentucky leadership NCCI new jersey new york ohio pennsylvania Safety safety at work state info tech technology the case manager violence WDYT what do you think women's history women's history month workers' comp 101 workers' recovery Workplace Safety Workplace Violence
Read Also
About The Author
About The Author
-
Frank Ferreri
Frank Ferreri, M.A., J.D. covers workers' compensation legal issues. He has published books, articles, and other material on multiple areas of employment, insurance, and disability law. Frank received his master's degree from the University of South Florida and juris doctor from the University of Florida Levin College of Law. Frank encourages everyone to consider helping out the Kind Souls Foundation and Kids' Chance of America.
More by This Author
Read More
- Nov 22, 2026
- Claire Muselman
- Nov 21, 2026
- Chris Parker
- Nov 21, 2026
- Claire Muselman
- Nov 21, 2026
- Frank Ferreri
- Nov 19, 2026
- Claire Muselman
- Nov 19, 2026
- Chriss Swaney