Magnifying Glass
banner 1090830 640
Back to Workers' Compensation Daily Headlines

What Do You Think: Was Physical Therapist’s ‘Stress Event’ Physical Injury?

25 May, 2023 Chris Parker

banner 1090830 640
                               

Albany, NY (WorkersCompensation.com) – It’s much easier for an employee to obtain workers’ compensation benefits in New York for a physical injury than for a “psychic” or mental injury. But what if a physical injury occurs because the worker’s mental state?

A case involving a physical therapist who suffered a myocardial infarction after talking to her supervisor (I think we’ve all been there), addresses that very question.

The therapist was talking to her supervisor about a shift change when she began to feel chest pain and nausea and started to sweat. She rushed to the emergency room, where a cardiologist determined, based on elevated troponin levels in her blood, that she had suffered a heart attack. The doctor also opined that the event was causally related to the therapist’s job.

The therapist sought workers’ compensation benefits on the basis that she suffered a heart attack as a result of work-related stress.

The workers’ compensation board denied the claim, reasoning that the therapist did not sustain a physical injury, but instead experienced "mild emotional distress and … a stress event.” It pointed out that a catheterization revealed no heart blockage and an echocardiogram the following day showed normal heart function.

Did the therapist suffer a physical injury?

A. Yes. While the injury arose from stress, the doctor concluded that the therapist had a heart attack.

B. No. The worker was fine, based on the diagnostic tests. Thus, she was not injured.



  • AI california case file caselaw case management case management focus claims compensability compliance compliance corner courts covid do you know the rule exclusive remedy florida FMLA glossary check Healthcare hr homeroom insurance insurers iowa leadership medical NCCI new jersey new york ohio pennsylvania roadmap Safety safety at work state info tech technology violence WDYT west virginia what do you think women's history women's history month workers' comp 101 workers' recovery Workplace Safety Workplace Violence

    • Read Also

    Could Worker Construct Compensable Claim from Bronchitis-Induced Buggy Crash?

    What Do You Think? Imagine that an Alabama employee has a host of medical conditions that put him at risk for injury. If one of those conditions causes him to have an accident, can he still obtain […]
    Lawmakers Call for Answers after Michigan Postal Worker Found Dead Inside Machine

    Safety at Work Allen Park, MI (WorkersCompensation.com) – Michigan Congress members want answers after a postal worker was found dead inside of a machine at a postal facility. Firefighters were called to the Allen Park, […]
    What does ‘Case Management’ Mean in Tennessee?

    Glossary Check If you were in the Volunteer State, and you had to define "case management" or "case manager" for workers' compensation purposes, could you do it? With Simply Research, you could. But we have […]

    About The Author

    • Chris Parker

    More by This Author

    Could Worker Construct Compensable Claim from Bronchitis-Induced Buggy Crash?

    What Do You Think? Imagine that an Alabama employee has a host of medical conditions that put him at risk for injury. If one of those conditions causes him to have an accident, can he still obtain […]
    Louisiana’s Exclusive Remedy Rule

    State Snapshot State Snapshot Louisiana Exclusive Remedy Rule BASIC RULE In Louisiana, the Workers’ Compensation Act provides the exclusive remedy for employees injured in the course and scope of employment. This means that employers are […]
    Did Restaurant Manager Cook up Claim that Floor Injured his Foot?

    What Do You Think? An employee can have a compensable claim when he was injured doing an ordinary activity at work that is not really job-related–such as walking. But he'll generally have to show that […]

    Read More

    Could Worker Construct Compensable Claim from Bronchitis-Induced Buggy Crash?

    What Do You Think? Imagine that an Alabama employee has a host of medical conditions that put him at risk for injury. If one of those conditions causes him to have an accident, can he still obtain […]
    Lawmakers Call for Answers after Michigan Postal Worker Found Dead Inside Machine

    Safety at Work Allen Park, MI (WorkersCompensation.com) – Michigan Congress members want answers after a postal worker was found dead inside of a machine at a postal facility. Firefighters were called to the Allen Park, […]
    What does ‘Case Management’ Mean in Tennessee?

    Glossary Check If you were in the Volunteer State, and you had to define "case management" or "case manager" for workers' compensation purposes, could you do it? With Simply Research, you could. But we have […]
    Reporting Requirements (& More) for Arizona Carriers

    Compliance Corner Let's say you're a carrier in Arizona. Would you know where to find the rules for reporting? A good place to start would be with one of Simply Research's compliance summaries, but we […]
    Business Strategy Class: Generative AI and the Workforce of Tomorrow 

    The Trained A-Eye Welcome back to class, classmates! We explored how AI supports individuals, strengthens organizations, and shapes culture. Now, time to talk about its most powerful influence yet: the workforce itself. In this week’s Business Strategy […]
    Building the Future of Workers’ Comp: DATA Mentors Find Meaning in Giving Back

    What's Good? DATA Bridges today’s leaders with tomorrow’s talent  The Diversity and Talent Alliance devotes itself to investing in the next generation of professionals who will lead the industry. In doing so, it pairs mentors […]