Magnifying Glass
banner 1090830 640
Back to Workers' Compensation Daily Headlines

What Do You Think: Was Physical Therapist’s ‘Stress Event’ Physical Injury?

25 May, 2023 Chris Parker

banner 1090830 640
                               

Albany, NY (WorkersCompensation.com) – It’s much easier for an employee to obtain workers’ compensation benefits in New York for a physical injury than for a “psychic” or mental injury. But what if a physical injury occurs because the worker’s mental state?

A case involving a physical therapist who suffered a myocardial infarction after talking to her supervisor (I think we’ve all been there), addresses that very question.

The therapist was talking to her supervisor about a shift change when she began to feel chest pain and nausea and started to sweat. She rushed to the emergency room, where a cardiologist determined, based on elevated troponin levels in her blood, that she had suffered a heart attack. The doctor also opined that the event was causally related to the therapist’s job.

The therapist sought workers’ compensation benefits on the basis that she suffered a heart attack as a result of work-related stress.

The workers’ compensation board denied the claim, reasoning that the therapist did not sustain a physical injury, but instead experienced "mild emotional distress and … a stress event.” It pointed out that a catheterization revealed no heart blockage and an echocardiogram the following day showed normal heart function.

Did the therapist suffer a physical injury?

A. Yes. While the injury arose from stress, the doctor concluded that the therapist had a heart attack.

B. No. The worker was fine, based on the diagnostic tests. Thus, she was not injured.



  • AI california case file caselaw case management case management focus claims compensability compliance courts covid do you know the rule exclusive remedy florida glossary check Healthcare health care hr homeroom insurance insurers iowa leadership medical NCCI new jersey new york ohio osha pennsylvania roadmap Safety safety at work state info tech technology violence WDYT what do you think women's history women's history month workcompcollege workers' comp 101 workers' recovery Workplace Safety Workplace Violence

    • Read Also

    How are Iowa Inmates Covered by Workers’ Compensation?

    Compliance Corner In Iowa, some inmates are covered under the state's workers' compensation law. While Simply Research subscribers have access to what the rules are for such workers, we take a look here.  Glossary Check […]
    S.D. Top Court doesn’t See ‘Arising Out Of’ or ‘In Course Of’ for Tech’s Side Hustle Detour

    25 for 25 in '25 Although an employer was fine with employees taking personal stops on business trips, such latitude for self-care did not extend to doing work for other employers. Simply Research subscribers have […]
    Could Widow Get Survivor Benefits after Officer Shot Himself at Work?

    What Do You Think? To be compensable, an injury must be caused by the job in some way. A case involving the suicide of a police officer shows how critical expert testimony can be to […]

    About The Author

    • Chris Parker

    More by This Author

    Could Widow Get Survivor Benefits after Officer Shot Himself at Work?

    What Do You Think? To be compensable, an injury must be caused by the job in some way. A case involving the suicide of a police officer shows how critical expert testimony can be to […]
    Bad Faith Penalties in New Mexico

    Do You Know the Rule? In New Mexico, employers and carriers may find themselves on the hook for payments beyond the workers’ compensation benefits they owe if a claimant shows they engaged in "bad faith." […]
    Could Widow Get Survivor Benefits after Officer Shot Himself at Work?

    What Do You Think? To be compensable, an injury must be caused by the job in some way. A case involving the suicide of a police officer shows how critical expert testimony can be to […]

    Read More

    How are Iowa Inmates Covered by Workers’ Compensation?

    Compliance Corner In Iowa, some inmates are covered under the state's workers' compensation law. While Simply Research subscribers have access to what the rules are for such workers, we take a look here.  Glossary Check […]
    S.D. Top Court doesn’t See ‘Arising Out Of’ or ‘In Course Of’ for Tech’s Side Hustle Detour

    25 for 25 in '25 Although an employer was fine with employees taking personal stops on business trips, such latitude for self-care did not extend to doing work for other employers. Simply Research subscribers have […]
    Could Widow Get Survivor Benefits after Officer Shot Himself at Work?

    What Do You Think? To be compensable, an injury must be caused by the job in some way. A case involving the suicide of a police officer shows how critical expert testimony can be to […]
    Trump’s Stiff Tariffs and Harsh Immigration Rules Creating Chaos for the U.S. Agriculture Industry  

    Labor Landscape The Trump administration’s assault on immigrants is starting to impact the American food chain as prices soar in grocery stores and more undocumented workers continue to leave the country.  In Texas, North Carolina, […]
    Bad Faith Penalties in New Mexico

    Do You Know the Rule? In New Mexico, employers and carriers may find themselves on the hook for payments beyond the workers’ compensation benefits they owe if a claimant shows they engaged in "bad faith." […]
    Cal-OSHA Recommends Charges against Company, while Critics Say Agency Undermanned

    Safety at Work San Leandro, CA (WorkersCompensation.com) – Cal-OSHA has recommended criminal charges against a metal recycling company where a third had died. Even though it is continuing to investigate and levy recommendations against the […]