3 Pa. Cases about Available Jobs

22 Nov, 2026 Frank Ferreri

                               
Key Cases

In Thomas v. Sysco Foods, No. 65 EAP 2024 (Pa. 11/17/26), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that an employer claiming that it has no job to offer a workers' compensation claimant has the burden of proof to show that a job doesn't exist. While a claimant may introduce evidence of an available job opening to rebut the employer’s offer of proof, the claimant is not required to, as the claimant does not have the burden.

In reaching its decision, the court looked at three cases to help make its decision. Here's what those cases said.

Rosenbeg v. Pike Cnty., 942 A.2d 245 (Pa. Commw. Ct. 2008). Held that the claimant carries the initial burden. The majority opined that any employer must demonstrate compliance with the mandate to offer a claimant any available job vacancy the claimant is capable of performing before relying on an earning power assessment based on jobs in the general labor market, but only when the claimant makes an allegation of noncompliance with prima facie evidence. In the Thomas case, the court found persuasive the dissenting opinion, which opined that the mandate does not create a presumption of compliance; instead, the mandate always places the burden on the employer, regardless of whether the claimant alleges the employer violated the mandate.

Barrett v. Otis Elevator, 246 A.2d 688 (Pa. 1969). Explained that the "special allocation" of the burden of proof onto a party to prove the non-existence of a fact can occur in a "limited class of cases, i.e., where the burden of proving a fact is said to be on the party who presumably has pecular means of knowledge."

Commonwealth v. Sanchez, 36 A.3d 24 (Pa. 2011). Observed that placing the burden of showing capacity to stand trial on the Commonwealth, instead of the burden of showing incapacity on the capital defendant, was undesirable because doing so would prevent the court from determining the true mental capacity of the defendant, as a burden on the Commonwealth would give defendants “less incentive to cooperate in psychiatric investigations, becausean inconclusive examination will benefit the defense, not the prosecution. A defendantmay also be less cooperative in making available friends or family who might haveinformation about the defendant’s mental state.”

Practice Point

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court views job availability as information uniquely within the employer's knowledge. As a result, employers seeking to modify benefits through a labor market survey must do more than simply identify jobs in the general labor market. They must also be prepared to show that no suitable position was available within their own organization. Claimants, meanwhile, are not required to identify available jobs before challenging a proposed modification.


  • AI best practices california case file caselaw case management case management focus claims compensability compliance compliance corner courts do you know the rule employers exclusive remedy florida fraud glossary check Healthcare hr homeroom insurance insurers iowa kentucky leadership NCCI new jersey new york ohio pennsylvania Safety safety at work state info tech technology the case manager violence WDYT what do you think women's history women's history month workers' comp 101 workers' recovery Workplace Safety Workplace Violence


  • Read Also

    About The Author

    • Frank Ferreri

      Frank Ferreri, M.A., J.D. covers workers' compensation legal issues. He has published books, articles, and other material on multiple areas of employment, insurance, and disability law. Frank received his master's degree from the University of South Florida and juris doctor from the University of Florida Levin College of Law. Frank encourages everyone to consider helping out the Kind Souls Foundation and Kids' Chance of America.

    Read More