Share This Article:
What Do You Think?
Does a worker forgo benefits from the person who is paying him just because the two have an informal working relationship? A recent case involving a man who occasionally helped an octogenarian repair garages and was injured during their final project sheds light on that question.
Angel Feliciano helped 84-year-old Frank Montero repair garage doors. Montero had operated a garage door installation business for more than 40 years before retiring at age 65. Still, he had continued doing small repair jobs when former customers or people who heard about him through word-of-mouth called. He didn’t advertise, though, or take on large projects. He generally worked only a few days a month and spent three or four months each winter in Puerto Rico not working.
Feliciano accompanied the older man on jobs about once every month or two, often after asking whether he could come along. Montero paid him in cash, generally $80 or $100 per day based on the job's size.
One day, Feliciano fell while working with Montero, seriously injuring his neck and back. He filed workers' compensation claims against Montero and Pennsylvania's Uninsured Employers Guaranty Fund. The Workers' Compensation Judge and Appeals Board denied the claims, and Feliciano appealed.
In Pennsylvania, an “employee” excludes individuals whose employment is both: 1) casual in character; and 2) outside the regular course of the employer's business.
Was Feliciano an employee entitled to workers' compensation benefits?
A. Yes. Feliciano performed garage door repairs and was paid for it. Also, this was the same type of work Montero had performed professionally for decades.
B. No. Feliciano's work was occasional and irregular, and Montero was no longer operating a regular business.
If you selected B, you agreed with the court in Feliciano v. Montero, No. 646 C.D. 2025 (Pa. Comm'w Ct. Nov. 4, 2026), which concluded that Feliciano was not an employee for purposes of workers’ compensation.
The court explained that casual employment generally involves occasional, irregular work performed for limited or temporary purposes rather than continuous employment. That was a fitting description of Feliciano's repair work, which occurred twice a month at most, and often at his own request. Further, there was no regular schedule and set pay.
Further, the work could not have been in the regular course of business because there was no regular business at the time. The older man had retired 20 years earlier, made no effort to market himself, and accepted only occasional, small jobs. It was also telling that he spent a big chunk of the year in Puerto Rico, not working at all. That Feliciano performed the same type of work Montero had once conducted professionally did not establish that the work occurred in the regular course of an existing business.
Because Feliciano's employment was both casual and outside the regular course of business, he was not entitled to workers' compensation benefits.
The claim was not compensable.
AI best practices california case file caselaw case management case management focus claims compensability compliance compliance corner courts do you know the rule employers exclusive remedy florida fraud glossary check Healthcare hr homeroom insurance insurers iowa kentucky leadership NCCI new jersey new york ohio pennsylvania Safety safety at work state info tech technology the case manager violence WDYT what do you think women's history women's history month workers' comp 101 workers' recovery Workplace Safety Workplace Violence
Read Also
About The Author
About The Author
- Chris Parker
More by This Author
- Nov 15, 2026
- Chris Parker
- Nov 10, 2026
- Chris Parker
Read More
- Nov 19, 2026
- Claire Muselman
- Nov 19, 2026
- Frank Ferreri
- Nov 18, 2026
- Claire Muselman
- Nov 18, 2026
- Anne Llewellyn
- Nov 16, 2026
- Claire Muselman
- Nov 16, 2026
- Frank Ferreri