Share This Article:
Arlington, VA (WorkersCompensation.com) - A reworking of a key piece of the workers compensation rating formula and a New York statute that could create significant new liabilities for workers compensation insurers were among the issues discussed by a panel of experts at the Casualty Actuarial Society's (CAS) Ratemaking and Product Management Seminar held March 12-13 in Huntington Beach, California.
The rating formula adjustment won't change rates overall, but it will change premiums for most insureds, said Tony DiDonato, FCAS, MAAA, director and senior actuary at the National Council on Compensation Insurance, the Boca Raton-based organization that estimates loss costs, the main block on which compensation rates are built.
The change, which took effect January 1, 2013, results in a slight decrease for most insureds, DiDonato said. But balancing out those many decreases will be some significant increases, often among the largest insureds, he said.
The change involves the experience mod, the credit (or debit) that insureds receive for their own claims experience. The mod compares an insured's claim experience to that of comparable employers. If experience is good, the insured gets a credit - a discount. If not, the insured receives a debit.
What's changing is the delineation between the primary and excess portions of a claim, known as the split point. For the past two decades, the split point has been $5,000. This value is important, because the primary portion of each claim has a much larger impact on an employer's mod than the excess portion - the idea being that the primary loss amount is more predictive than the excess amount.
But inflation has both eroded the primary/excess split point and hurt its predictive power. These days, the mod doesn't give enough credit to good experience and doesn't penalize poor experience enough.
“The plan was not being as predictive as it used to be” in distinguishing between good and bad risks, DiDonato said.
The change: Raising the split point – to $10,000 in 2013, to $13,500 in 2014, and to an estimated $17,000 in 2015. These adjustments, incorporated into the entire rating formula, improve the experience mod's predictive power.
In 26 of the 38 states where the plan has been approved, NCCI actuaries sampled 75,007 risks, calculating the experience mod under each system.
The result: The vast majority - 62 percent - would see their rates fall less than 5 percent. Another 11 percent realized decreases between 5 percent and 10 percent. Rates were unchanged for 4.5 percent of risks. Less than one in four would see a rate increase.
Overall, the average mod was 0.98 - a 2 percent discount - under the old system and 0.97 - a 3 percent discount - under the new system. DiDonato attributed the slight change to vagaries in the states where the new system had been approved. All NCCI states have approved the changes to the plan.
A separate set of changes in New York could leave insurers under-reserved, said Julia Stenberg, FCAS, MAAA, an assistant vice president and actuary at CNA insurance companies. The issue here is a proposal to end an unusual element in New York's comp law, the reopened case fund. Stenberg explained that the structure could create a reserve deficiency among New York comp writers.
The issue emerged as part of a package of reforms proposed earlier this year as part of the state budget. The best-known part of the proposal would create bonds to pay off losses from failed self-insured comp plans. But Stenberg indicated that attention should also be focused on the end of the reopened case fund.
In New York, cases that reopen three years after an insurer made what it thought was final payment (and seven years after the original accident) can be turned over to a reopened case fund run by the New York Compensation Insurance Rating Board (NYCIRB). Employers pay an assessment that covers these claims.
Under the proposal, the fund, created in 1933, would close January 1, 2014. Insurers would remain responsible for any reopened claims.
The closing creates an actuarial issue, Stenberg said. Because these reopened claims were handled by NYCIRB, the losses aren't included in an insurer's claims experience.
To handle pricing, data collected by the NYCIRB will be available to rating bureaus, so rates can be properly adjusted. However, insurers won't have that information, so their loss estimates will likely be understated. Stenberg estimated the deficiency to be between $1 billion and $2 billion.
“It's something important to consider if [an insurer has] exposure there or your clients have exposure there,” Stenberg said.
The Casualty Actuarial Society fulfills its mission to advance actuarial science through a singular focus on research and education for property/casualty actuarial practice. Among its 5,700 members are experts in property-casualty insurance, reinsurance, finance, risk management, and enterprise risk management
King of Prussia, Pa. (September 19, 2023) – MedRisk, the leader in managed physical rehabilitation in workers’ compensation, today announced the appointment of its President Sri Sridharan to Chief Executive Officer, effective immediately. As CEO, Mr. Sridharan will […]
- Sep 19, 2023
WorkCompCollege.com Launches Unique State-Specific Training Program for Workers’ Compensation Stakeholders
September 18, 2023 Lakewood Ranch, FL – WorkCompCollege.com, a division of Workers’ Compensation Educational Services, LLC, announced the launch of an innovative series of training modules covering the unique aspects of each workers’ compensation jurisdiction […]
- Sep 18, 2023
Las Vegas, NEV (September 7, 2023) – Since the pandemic, employers and workers’ compensation carriers have been refining their claims strategies to address the historic increase in anxiety, depression and substance abuse. “We have looked at […]
- Sep 12, 2023
About The Author
About The Author
More by This Author
ReEmployAbility, Inc.Contact: Rebecca Dearth(813) 261-3117 | firstname.lastname@example.org Brandon, FL (May 10, 2023)- ReEmployAbility CEO and Founder Debra Livingston will be hosting a second free, live Work Comp Central webinar in their continued series to educate […]
- May 11, 2023
(Orlando, FL–May 10, 2023)—The National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) has given $25,000 to Kids’ Chance of America, supporting college scholarships for the children of injured workers. NCCI made the donation in conjunction with its Annual […]
- May 10, 2023
In response to a Medicare conditional payment demand, payers can access a five-level appeals process, including a hearing before a Centers for Medicaid and Medicaid Services (CMS) administrative law judge (ALJ). Most conditional payment demand […]
- Mar 30, 2023
- Sep 19, 2023
- Sep 18, 2023
- Sep 12, 2023
Brandon, FL (September 6th, 2023)- ReEmployAbility is happy to announce its sponsorship of The Spring of Tampa Bay’s Gift of Peace Luncheon. ReEmployAbility’s CEO and founder is a proud board member for the Spring of […]
- Sep 08, 2023
Wilmington, Mass. (September 5, 2023) — Ametros, which helps people manage their medical funds following workers’ compensation or liability settlements, has expanded its C-Suite with the promotions of two accomplished executives. As of September 1, Andrea […]
- Sep 06, 2023
August 31, 2023 (BOCA RATON, FL)—The National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) celebrated 100 years of service to the workers compensation (WC) system with an event honoring its employees and a century of service to […]
- Sep 05, 2023