Magnifying Glass
yes 941500 640
Back to Archives

How the Court Ruled

10 Jul, 2023 Chris Parker

yes 941500 640
                               

If you chose B, you sided with the court in Nickey v. Saint Rose Dominican Hosp., No. 84688-COA (Nev. Ct. App. 06/28/23), which held that the nurse’s injury arose out of personal, not work-related circumstances. 

The court pointed out that the video showed the nurse was animated and closely approached the patient, and that at the time, the patient was seated and made no attempt to get up. 

“[The nurse] got within one foot of the [the patient’s] face for no medical reason before the patient slapped her,” the court wrote. Because the nurse did not need to take such action to perform her job, she was exceeding her employment when she was injured. 

Because the evidence indicated that the nurse escalated the situation and created an unnecessary confrontation which resulted in her injury, her injury did not arise out of her employment and was not compensable under Nevada workers’ compensation law. 

    • Read Also

    What Do You Think: Was Firing Nurse who Lost Fight with Door WC Retaliation? 

    Belleville, NJ (Workerscompensation.com). An employer’s action during the period after which an employee reports an injury and the date she is fired can go a long way to either showing retaliation or negating it.   A […]
    How the Court Ruled

    If you chose B, you sided with the court in Herron v. New York City Transit, No. 22-989-cv (2d Cir. 06/30/23), which held that the worker failed to show that the Authority’s explanation for firing him […]
    How the Court Ruled

    If you chose A, you sided with the court in Arizmendi v. Rich Products Corp., No. C.D. 2022 (Pa. Comm’w Ct. 12/07/22), which held that the worker did not have a serious health condition. The court […]

    About The Author

    • Chris Parker

    More by This Author

    What Do You Think: Can Electrocuted Crane Disassembler Sue General Contractor?

    Lawrenceville, GA (WorkersCompensation.com) – Generally, an injured employee cannot sue his employer for negligence for a work-related injury. But what if the employee is not strictly employed by the company he wants to sue, but […]
    What Do You Think: Did Nurse Link Infection to Nursing Home where COVID Ran Rampant? 

    Madison, MS (WorkersCompensation.com)–A nurse who contracts COVID-19 while working at a medical facility where the people are getting the virus left and right may, intuitively, and based on common sense, know she contracted the illness […]
    Do You Know the Rule? Md. Last Injurious Exposure

    Catonsville, MD (WorkersCompensation.com) — When an occupational disease develops over time, and a worker has had multiple employers exposing him to a potential hazard connected to the condition, it becomes very difficult to establish which […]

    Read More

    What Do You Think: Was Firing Nurse who Lost Fight with Door WC Retaliation? 

    Belleville, NJ (Workerscompensation.com). An employer’s action during the period after which an employee reports an injury and the date she is fired can go a long way to either showing retaliation or negating it.   A […]
    How the Court Ruled

    If you chose B, you sided with the court in Herron v. New York City Transit, No. 22-989-cv (2d Cir. 06/30/23), which held that the worker failed to show that the Authority’s explanation for firing him […]
    How the Court Ruled

    If you chose A, you sided with the court in Arizmendi v. Rich Products Corp., No. C.D. 2022 (Pa. Comm’w Ct. 12/07/22), which held that the worker did not have a serious health condition. The court […]
    How the Court Ruled

    If you chose B, you sided with the court in Barker v. Sam Houston State University, No. 06-22-00076-CV (Tex. Ct. App. 06/22/23), which held that the professor, though not engaging in work at the time, […]
    How the Court Ruled

    If you chose B, you sided with the court in Basset v. Town of East Haven., No. AC 45106 (Conn. App. Ct. 06/26/22), which held that lighting the device was outside the course of employment.  The […]
    Today is Juneteenth; Our Offices are Closed

    Sarasota, FL (WorkersCompensation.com) — In commemoration of the Juneteenth holiday, our offices are closed for Monday, June 19. Usual business will resume Tuesday morning. Please take a few moments to study up on Juneteenth, courtesy […]

    Request a Demo

    To request a free demo of one of our products, please fill in this form. Our sales team will get back to you shortly.