Explainable AI in Workers’ Compensation: A Practical, Ethical Guide for Claims, Legal, and Medical Professionals

                               

The MedLegal Professor’s Technology Lab™ Series

By Nikki Mehrpoo, AIHI, AIWC, AIMWC – The MedLegal Professor™

Featured on WorkersCompensation.com | Powered by MedLegalProfessor.ai

Discover how explainable AI protects attorneys, adjusters, and claims teams from risk. Real-world guidance, ethical tech use, and compliance strategy. Start using AI the right way.

From Overwhelm to Empowerment: Making Sense of AI in Workers’ Compensation

Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly becoming a cornerstone of the workers’ compensation system. Yet many professionals—including claims adjusters, attorneys, nurse case managers, risk managers, and employers—still ask:

• What does AI really do in workers’ comp?
• Will it help me or eventually replace me?
• How can I ensure the tech is fair, legal, and transparent?

These questions are not signs of resistance. They are signs of leadership. The truth is: You do not need to become an engineer. You need to become an ethical, informed user.

👉 Start here: Ask your vendor or IT lead, “What exactly does this AI tool do, and can I see a sample of its decision-making?”

This article breaks it all down with clarity, practical examples, and real-world legal-medical relevance.

What Is Explainable AI and Why Does It Matter in Workers’ Comp?

Explainable AI (XAI) is a form of artificial intelligence that allows humans to understand, audit, and justify the logic behind an automated decision. It shows its work, just like we teach professionals to do in court, clinical review, and compliance audits.

AI Tools That Work for You, Not Around You

• Non-explainable AI: “Flag this claim.” No reasons. No trace.
• Explainable AI: “Flagged for X due to pattern Y in Document Z” with a full logic trail.

Benefits of Explainable AI:

• Verifiable reasoning
• Audit-readiness
• Legal defensibility
• Early error detection
• Ethical alignment

🛠️ Practical Tip: Look for tools with a “click-and-trace” feature. You should be able to click on any AI-generated flag or recommendation and see exactly what triggered it.

“Invisible AI makes visible mistakes.”

How AI Is Already Shaping Claims and Compliance Workflows

AI is already being used to:

• Prioritize incoming claims
• Flag potential fraud
• Evaluate medical necessity
• Auto-deny or authorize treatment
• Recommend settlements

These systems are influencing everything from litigation risk to patient outcomes. That is why understanding them is not optional.

“When you cannot explain AI, it is not just a tech issue. It is a liability.”

🛠️ Practical Tip: For every AI recommendation, ask: “Can I explain this decision to a judge, regulator, or injured worker?” If not, the system may be putting your license or your case at risk.

The AI + HI™ Model: Combining Automation with Human Oversight

At MedLegalProfessor.AI™, we use the AI + HI™ framework, where AI means automation and HI means human intelligence—judgment, ethics, and accountability.

“You don’t need to code it. You need to control it.”

AI + HI™ = Faster results + Ethical review + Trustworthy output

🛠️ Practical Tip: Assign one “AI reviewer” per team. Their job is to check if outputs align with legal, medical, and operational standards. No AI tool should be left unsupervised.

Why Explainability Is Now a Compliance Requirement

When AI is used to:

• Deny treatment
• Refer a claim to Special Investigations
• Auto-settle indemnity exposure
• Flag a doctor for overutilization

…it is not just automation. It is adjudication.

Leaders and their teams across the industry must understand and be able to explain the AI’s involvement. Whether you manage a claims desk or legal practice, you need to know how the system reached its conclusion and what role humans played.

🛠️ Practical Tip: Build AI literacy into your compliance strategy. Ask during training: “Who can explain this decision? Who signed off? Is it traceable?” That question builds a culture of ethical accountability.

Five Questions Every Claims Leader Must Ask Before Using AI Tools

Before you trust a claims triage tool, automation engine, or predictive model, ask:

1. Can I clearly explain the decision to a peer, claimant, or regulator?
2. Can I see the underlying documents or data it used?
3. Can I correct or override its output if needed?
4. Does the vendor allow human review of all outputs?
5. Is there an audit trail that documents the full process?

If the answer to any is “no,” you are operating without a net.

🛠️ Practical Tip: Post these five questions at every review desk. Use them as a readiness test before onboarding any system.

Common Red Flags: When AI Tools Create Legal and Ethical Risk

Avoid tools that:

• Use mystery “scores” with no justification
• Make irreversible decisions
• Offer “just trust us” logic
• Lack downloadable logs or reports

No human judgment? No human justice.

🛠️ Practical Tip: In every vendor demo, ask: “Can you walk me through how I would audit or override this system’s decision?” If they hesitate, you should too.

Case Study: Avoiding a Lawsuit With Explainable AI

A national TPA flagged a “high-risk” claim using AI. A senior reviewer noticed that the tool had factored in ZIP code and age—potentially discriminatory inputs.

Because the system was explainable, the logic trail was visible. They corrected the recommendation, documented the oversight, and avoided liability.

Result: No lawsuit. No bad press. Just responsible tech and strong human review.

🛠️ Practical Tip: Run random monthly audits of AI-flagged claims. This helps detect hidden bias and ensures your system holds up under legal review.

Checklist: What to Look for in an AI Tool for Legal or Claims Use

Your AI tool must have:

• Transparent training data and logic
• Explainable recommendations
• Human override or approval checkpoints
• Role-specific customization (legal, clinical, claims)
• Downloadable audit logs
• Responsive support team

🛠️ Practical Tip: In your tool vetting spreadsheet, add a column: “Could I explain this to a judge?” Rate each vendor on that question alone.

Start Here: Simple Ways to Make Your Team AI-Ready Today

• Designate an AI ethics reviewer per department
• Include “AI explainability” in every vendor contract
• Train teams on your five-question audit
• Create escalation protocols for AI-generated errors
• Use human-in-the-loop workflows in every automation process

🛠️ Practical Tip: Empower every team member—legal, claims, or clinical—to say: “I do not trust that AI output. Let us review it together.” That one statement can protect lives, licenses, and livelihoods.

FAQ: Explainable AI in Workers’ Compensation

What is explainable AI in workers’ compensation?

AI that provides clear reasons for its decisions, like why a claim was flagged or denied.

Why does it matter for adjusters and attorneys?

It protects legal defensibility, promotes fairness, and reduces the risk of bias or error.

Can AI replace human adjusters or reviewers?

No. Explainable AI supports professionals but cannot replace ethical judgment.

How do I know if a tool is safe to use?

Use the five-question test. If the system lacks traceability or auditability, it is not safe.

🔍 MedLegal Insight™

“AI can help you get started. AI can help you move faster. But only you can make it right, legal, and worth trusting.”

This is not about tools. This is about trust.

🛠️ Practical Tip: Use this quote in your next team training or compliance meeting. Let it set the tone for how you use automation with judgment, not overconfidence.

📢 Take the Next Step: Empower Your Team with Ethical AI

Still using tools you cannot explain? Time to upgrade.

👉 Visit MedLegalProfessor.AI to explore:

📧 Contact The MedLegal Professor at Hello@MedLegalProfesdor.AI

🎓 Want to learn more? Join us live every Monday at 12:00 PM PST

The MedLegal Professor™ hosts a free weekly webinar on AI, compliance, and innovation in workers’ compensation, law, and medicine.

🔗 Register here: https://my.demio.com/ref/OpMMDaPZCHP3qFnh?fbclid=IwY2xjawJ7jr1leHRuA2FlbQIxMQBicmlkETF3WFNMZXNzQXBBY2lmakN3AR72dVyzGtHC_7_U_vQz-1d7RKJsn1Pu4I-l-g_thn0wMTEwd_9g32TvWOK4WQ_aem_-7uOCq_tpDxtPiKEsneaxg

🔖 Final Thought from The MedLegal Professor™

These tools will not replace you. They will elevate you.

But only if they are built for ethics, not just efficiency.

We do not fix broken systems with shinier software.

We fix them with smarter professionals, stronger oversight, and explainable AI.

👉 Subscribe to The MedLegal Professor™ Newsletter

📣 Call to Action: Educate. Empower. Elevate.™